Impact of Flow Meter Accuracy

When discussing about flow metering, a number of terms are important to consider, which include Repeatability, Uncertainty, Accuracy and Turndown, are commonly used.

Repeatability

This describes the ability of a flow meter to indicate the same value for an identical flow rate on more than one occasion.

It should not be confused with accuracy i.e. its repeatability may be excellent in that it shows the same value for an identical flow rate on several occasions, but the reading might be consistently wrong (or inaccurate).

Good repeatability is important. However, this does not dilute the importance of accuracy under any circumstances.

Uncertainty

The term ‘uncertainty’ is now becoming more commonly referred to than accuracy.

This is because accuracy cannot be established, as the true value can never be exactly known.

However ‘uncertainty’ can be estimated and an ISO standard exists offering guidance on this matter (EN ISO/IEC 17025).

It is important to recognise that it is a statistical concept and not a guarantee.

For example, it may be shown that with a large population of flow meters, 95% would be at least as good as the uncertainty calculated. Most would be much better, but a few, 5% could be worse.

Accuracy

This is a measure of a flow meter’s performance when indicating a correct flow rate value against a ‘true’ value obtained by extensive calibration procedures. The subject of accuracy is dealt with in ISO 5725.

The following two methods used to express accuracy have very different meanings:

Percentage of measured value or actual reading

For example, a flow meter’s accuracy is given as ±3% of actual flow.

At an indicated flow rate of 1000 kg/h, the ‘uncertainty’ of actual flow is between:

1000 – 3% = 970 kg/h

And

1000 + 3% = 1 030 kg/h

Similarly, at an indicated flow rate of 500 kg/h, the error is still ±3%, and the ‘uncertainty’ is between:

500 kg/h – 3% = 485 kg/h

And

500 kg/h + 3% = 515 kg/h

Percentage of full scale deflection (FSD)

A flow meter’s accuracy may also be given as a percentage of full scale deflection FSD, which means that the measurement error is expressed as a percentage of the maximum flow that the flow meter can handle.

Error stated in percentage FSD tends to be smaller than the error as a percentage of actual reading.

For this example a value of ±0.3% FSD will be used.

As in the previous case, the maximum flow = 1000 kg/h.

At an indicated flowrate of 1000 kg/h, the ‘uncertainty’ of actual flow is between:

1000 kg/h – 0.3% = 997 kg/h

And

1000 kg/h + 0.3% = 1003 kg/h

At an indicated flowrate of 50 kg/h, the error is still ±3 kg/h, and the actual flow is between:

50 kg/h – 3 kg/h = 47 kg/h an error of – 6%

And

50 kg/h + 3 kg/h = 53 kg/h an error of +6%

As the flowrate is reduced, the percentage error increases.

Flow Meter Accuracy

A comparison of these measurement terms is shown graphically in Figure