Home » Hydrostatic Level Measurement – Temperature related Density Change Effects
Question For You

Hydrostatic Level Measurement – Temperature related Density Change Effects

Hydrostatic Level Measurement – Temperature related Density Change

Question :

An open vessel contains water at 60 oF. A pressure transmitter located at the bottom of the vessel measures the hydrostatic pressure (“head”) generated by the water and outputs a signal corresponding to level. Suppose that the temperature of this vessel were to increase over time to 110 oF due to exposure to very hot outside air.

Knowing that an increase in water temperature will result in a decrease in density, what will happen to the level transmitter’s output as the vessel heats up? Will the transmitter output increase, decrease, or stay the same? Why?? Assume that no water enters or exits the vessel during the period of heating from 60 oF to 110 oF.

Answer :

The transmitter output will stay the same.

If you thought that the transmitter output would decrease due to the water becoming less dense, I recommend you explore the concept of density a little deeper with the following “thought experiment:”

  • Imagine the vessel filled half-way with liquid.
  • Imagine that liquid heating up and expanding until it is only half as dense as it was at the beginning of the experiment.
  • Calculate the new hydrostatic pressure with the expanded, less-dense liquid.

In a way, this is a “trick” question. As any given mass of water heats up, its volume will increase. This is what makes it less dense than before: increased volume with the same mass (weight). Knowing how to calculate hydrostatic pressure from height and specific gravity, you might have approached this problem by assuming the water column height would have stayed the same while its density decreased, resulting in a lesser hydrostatic pressure and decreased transmitter output. However, this answer is incorrect.

If the water volume expands as a result of a temperature increase, the level inside the vessel must rise, because it will require a higher vessel level to contain a greater volume of water. The level will rise by the same percentage that the density decreases, resulting in a cancellation of level increase with density decrease. As a result, the hydrostatic pressure at any point in the vessel remains constant.

If you have difficulty picturing this effect, consider an exaggerated example to make things simpler. Suppose that a vessel has been filled to a height of 10 feet with cold liquid:

hydrostatic pressure Transmitter Calculations

Now, imagine that same vessel being heated until the liquid expands to exactly twice its former volume:

liquid level Measurement

The liquid level must double to accommodate twice the volume in the same vessel, assuming a vessel of constant diameter, and its density will be cut in half (twice the volume with the same mass). Consequently, the two factors of liquid level change and liquid density change cancel each other out to give the exact same hydrostatic pressure as before.

In other words, the transmitter will register the same liquid level as it did when the liquid was cold, and will output the exact same signal, even though the actual vessel level is quite a bit more than it was when cold. Pretty tricky, huh?

Note : This concept applies to this particular case study/question. In most cases temperature effects the DP Transmitter readings especially if it is capillary type.

Also Read : Hydrostatic Interface Level Measurement

Related Articles

Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) Questions and Answers – 9

S Bharadwaj Reddy

PLC Programming Questions & Answers – 1

S Bharadwaj Reddy

Measure the Temperature of the RTD

S Bharadwaj Reddy

Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) Questions and Answers – 19

S Bharadwaj Reddy

Practical Process Control System Questions & Answers – 19

S Bharadwaj Reddy

How Overload Heaters used to Automatically Shut the Motor OFF ?

S Bharadwaj Reddy

2 comments

nishtha June 6, 2018 at 12:45 am

Please show its mathematical proof.

Reply
sagar June 6, 2018 at 8:50 am

For mathematical proof please refer A.K.sawhney measurement book and k. krishnaswamy industrial instrumentation.
for more help put your question on my [email protected]

Reply

Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More