Comparison of Pressure Instruments – Industrial Instrumentation

The pressure instruments or pressure transducers come in a variety of forms, each with specific applications, advantages, and disadvantages.

Comparison of Pressure Instruments

The below table shows the comparison of various types of pressure instruments, covering their operating principles, advantages, and disadvantages.

S.No.	Instrument Type	Operating Theory	Advantages	Disadvantages
1	Bourdon Tube	Flexing of a C-shaped or helical tube when pressure is applied	Simple, reliable, low cost	Limited accuracy, not suitable for low-pressure measurement
2	Diaphragm	Flexing of a membrane due to pressure differential	Good for low pressures, corrosion-resistant	Limited high-pressure capacity, may require frequent calibration
3	Bellows	Expansion and contraction of a cylindrical chamber	Sensitive to low pressures, simple construction	Susceptible to mechanical wear, limited high-pressure capability
4	Manometer	Liquid column height change due to pressure differential	Simple, low cost, high accuracy	Limited to low pressures, influenced by temperature and gravity
5	Piezoelectric Sensor	Generates voltage proportional to applied pressure	Fast response, good for dynamic pressures	Limited to dynamic measurements, sensitive to temperature
6	Strain Gauge	Change in electrical resistance due to mechanical strain	High accuracy, good for static and dynamic pressures	Requires complex electronics, sensitive to temperature
7	Capacitive Sensor	Change in capacitance due to diaphragm deflection	Suitable for wide pressure range, high accuracy	Susceptible to temperature drift, complex electronics required
8	Optical Pressure Sensor	Light intensity or wavelength changes with pressure	High sensitivity, immune to electrical noise	Expensive, not suitable for all industrial applications

The below table shows the comparison of features, accuracy, range, cost, maintenance, and installation of commonly used types of pressure meters.

Parameter	Bourdon Tube	Bellows	Diaphragm	Piezoelectric	Capacitive	Strain Gauge	Optical	Ionization
Principle of Operation	Mechanical	Mechanical	Mechanical	Piezoelectric effect	Capacitance	Electrical resistance	Light wavelength	Ionized gas
Pressure Range	Low to High	Low to Moderate	Low to Moderate	Moderate to High	Low to High	Low to High	Low to High	Very High
Accuracy	Moderate	Moderate	High	High	High	High	Very High	Very High
Response Time	Moderate	Slow	Moderate	Fast	Fast	Fast	Fast	Fast
Temperature Sensitivity	Moderate	High	High	Moderate	Moderate	Moderate	Low	Low
Cost	Low	Low	Moderate	High	Moderate	Moderate	High	Very High
Maintenance	Moderate	High	Moderate	Low	Low	Low	Low	High
Fluid Compatibility	Broad	Limited	Broad	Limited	Broad	Broad	Broad	Limited
Durability	High	Moderate	High	Moderate	High	High	High	Moderate
Electrical Requirements	None	None	None	Required	Required	Required	Required	Required
Ease of Installation	Easy	Moderate	Moderate	Moderate	Moderate	Moderate	Moderate	Difficult
Safety Aspects	Generally Safe	Limited	Generally Safe	Limited	Generally Safe	Generally Safe	Safe	Limited

Explanation of terms:

• Principle of Operation: The fundamental physical or mechanical principle used to measure pressure.
• Pressure Range: The range of pressure values that the meter is capable of measuring.
• Accuracy: The precision of the measurements.
• Response Time: The speed at which the meter responds to pressure changes.
• Temperature Sensitivity: How sensitive the meter is to changes in temperature.
• Cost: Relative cost to purchase and install the meter.
• Maintenance: The extent of maintenance required to keep the meter in optimal operating condition.
• Fluid Compatibility: Types of fluids (liquids or gases) for which the meter is suitable.
• Durability: The meter’s ability to withstand wear and tear over time.
• Electrical Requirements: Whether or not the meter requires electrical power for operation.
• Ease of Installation: How easy it is to install the meter.
• Safety Aspects: How suitable the meter is for use in hazardous or extreme conditions.

This table aims to provide a basic comparison to help you understand the distinct types of pressure instruments available. Each type has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, which should be considered based on the specific requirements of your application.

If you liked this article, then please subscribe to our YouTube Channel for Instrumentation, Electrical, PLC, and SCADA video tutorials.

You can also follow us on Facebook and Twitter to receive daily updates.

Read Next:

• Sloping Impulse Lines Advantages
• Pressure Transmitters Purge Lines
• Impulse Tubing Leak Test Checks
• Transmitter Heat-traced impulse line
• DP Transmitter Wet Leg Questions